Penn State's football program is facing a crossroads, and the solution being floated by one prominent analyst is so audacious, it's almost unbelievable: Should the Nittany Lions pick up the phone and call Nick Saban? Yes, that Nick Saban.
Following a disappointing loss to Northwestern, sealing a 3-3 record, Penn State made the drastic move of parting ways with head coach James Franklin. While Franklin led the team to a Final Four appearance just last season, fan discontent had been brewing for some time. The pressure is now on Penn State to make a 'home run' coaching hire, as another misstep could send the program into a downward spiral, potentially setting them back years.
Enter Joel Klatt, a widely respected voice in college football analysis. During a conversation with Colin Cowherd, Klatt proposed a strategy that raised eyebrows across the nation. "If I were [PSU AD] Pat Kraft," Klatt stated with unwavering conviction, "I would start with the biggest swing possible. I know this sounds crazy, but I think the first call I would make is Nick Saban. Just make sure that's not going to happen, and then you start going down the list of the other coaches around the country."
You can find the full video of his comments online.
Klatt's suggestion, while seemingly far-fetched, stems from a logical place. What does Penn State have to lose by reaching out? Saban's resume speaks for itself: seven national championships (six with Alabama and one with LSU), solidifying his place as arguably the greatest college football coach of all time. The question then becomes, does the legendary coach have one more act left?
But here's where it gets controversial... While the idea of Saban gracing the sidelines in Happy Valley might ignite the dreams of Nittany Lions fans, let's inject a dose of reality.
Saban will turn 74 later this month. He's currently enjoying a lucrative role as an analyst on College GameDay, and by all accounts, seems content with his life in retirement. Would he truly want to shoulder the immense pressure of rebuilding a program like Penn State, especially at this stage in his life?
And this is the part most people miss: Even if Saban was interested, would Penn State be the right fit for him? His success at Alabama and LSU was built on a foundation of unparalleled recruiting power and institutional support. Could Penn State provide the same level of resources and commitment?
It's a fascinating hypothetical scenario to consider, debate, and dissect.
One counterpoint to consider: Perhaps the appeal for Saban wouldn't be about a long-term rebuild, but rather a short, impactful stint to leave one final mark on the sport, and cement his legacy in a new environment. But is that realistic?
This raises a bigger question: What kind of coach should Penn State be targeting? A proven winner with a track record of success, or a rising star with the potential to build a dynasty? Or perhaps a coach with deep ties to the program and a passion for the Nittany Lions?
So, should Penn State at least try to contact Nick Saban? Who would you like to see take the reins in State College? Let your voice be heard in the comments below. Do you agree with Klatt's bold suggestion, or is it a pipe dream? And what qualities are most important in Penn State's next head coach? We want to know!
